Upcoming Events
Log In
Pricing
Free Trial

Radial Tears

HIDE
PrevNext

0:00

The third basic type of tear is very different.

0:04

And these are the tricky ones. These are the radial tears.

0:07

They also begin typically at or near the tip

0:11

or apex of the meniscus, but they are not circumferential.

0:16

All right? They extend from the central portion

0:20

to the periphery,

0:21

and as they do, they violate the longitudinal

0:24

circumferential collagen bundles.

0:27

So here's what they look like in my

0:29

three dimensional diagram.

0:30

This is what it looks like.

0:32

Uh, this of course, some of you know,

0:34

is the bow tie more about that in a moment.

0:36

But you can see the radial tear, which is extended

0:40

very sharply,

0:42

and you can see how sharp is the abnormality extending

0:45

out to the periphery.

0:46

And the more sagittal images that show it, the longer

0:50

that radial tear.

0:52

Okay? So you can appreciate.

0:54

Now, what do these collagen bundles do?

0:57

They tie together the anterior posterior

1:00

portions of the meniscus.

1:01

So you can imagine with a long radial tear, with violation

1:06

of a lot of those longitudinal circumferential

1:10

collagen bundles, you may get a, a gap at the site

1:15

of the radial tear.

1:17

Here's what it looks like.

1:19

I'm putting in this tear in yellow.

1:21

It's like the radial tie fibers here.

1:24

You can see violation

1:25

of those longitudinal circumferential fibers.

1:29

So it's not surprising. You will see images like this.

1:33

And I can remember very clearly the first time I saw

1:36

something like this, it was in a patient with a tear

1:39

of the anterior cruciate ligament.

1:41

And I spent approximately 20 minutes of my life trying

1:46

to find the missing piece of the meniscus.

1:49

It's not missing, right?

1:51

What you're seeing is a meniscal gap at the site

1:55

of a large radial tear.

1:57

So that's what occurs over a period of time, you will end up

2:01

with a meniscal gap.

2:02

It's like opening a book. All right? Be aware of that.

2:06

Don't waste your time as I did. And the bow tie.

2:11

So normally, particularly as we look in the sagittal images,

2:15

you will see separation

2:16

of the anter posterior horns in a very nice clean fashion.

2:21

And when you deal with radial tears, even small ones,

2:25

these will separate and often have sharp margins,

2:28

not pointed as you can see in the image at the top right.

2:33

Now, let's go ahead and image that one.

2:35

I'm imaging this one right along the axis

2:40

of the radial pair.

2:41

So what do I see? I see nothing.

2:44

This is an absent or empty meniscus.

2:46

It's an old image, but I like it.

2:48

Here's the anterior horn of the medial meniscus,

2:51

and that is fluid where the posterior horn should be.

2:55

So I've imaged this right along the gap associated

2:59

with a large radial tear.

3:02

Large single or multiple radial pairs are frequent in

3:06

discoid lateral meniscus.

3:07

This is a beautiful example of one broad, large radial tear.

3:12

I'll show you later some that are multiple radial pairs

3:15

with discoid meniscus.

3:18

A displaced radial tear is called a parrot beak tear

3:22

resembling the curvature of a parrot beak.

3:24

So let's draw one on this meniscus.

3:27

'cause this is important. This is critical. Let's image it.

3:30

We're gonna image it. Here's my first image. What do I see?

3:35

I see a vertical line, fairly straight, top

3:38

to bottom in the inner margin of the meniscus

3:42

or longitudinal vertical tears we see in the outer half.

3:46

So I'm a little bit suspicious

3:47

that's not a longitudinal vertical tear.

3:50

Let's image it again. We image it again in this particular

3:53

type of tear, that cleft

3:57

is marching in this case toward the tip of the meniscus.

4:00

This is known as the marching cleft sign.

4:04

So the general rule is vertical lines in the inner aspect,

4:08

and I'll say the inner half of the meniscus usually

4:12

indicate radial tears

4:14

or parrot B tears, displaced radial tears.

4:17

Here's a drawing of this particular tear.

4:20

I'm imaging it in the sagittal plane, A, B, and C.

4:25

And here is a broad marching cleft marching from the inner

4:28

margin out toward the periphery.

4:31

Alright? Be aware

4:33

that these radial pairs can look longitudinal vertical,

4:37

but they're in the inner half of the meniscus.

4:41

Now, this also is a critical side.

4:45

Typically when dealing with sagittal images

4:48

and the medial aspect of the knee

4:51

will image the posterior cruciate ligament.

4:54

Here in the next medial image, you should see a lot

4:58

of the posterior horn of the medial meniscus.

5:01

And in the second medial image away from the PCL,

5:06

the entire posterior horn

5:08

of the medial meniscus should be seen.

5:12

So let's look at this case here.

5:15

It's an old case, but you can see here's the PCL,

5:19

there's nothing there.

5:20

Here's my next image.

5:22

And that does not look like a normal meniscus.

5:25

That is abnormal.

5:27

So this is a problem involving the inner aspect

5:31

of the posterior horn, of the medial meniscus.

5:34

And it's obvious when you go to the coronal plane

5:38

that you can see, in fact, rather than the normal situation

5:42

where the posterior horn dives down

5:44

as the posterior root ligament, we can see

5:47

that there is a tear, perhaps a radial tear

5:50

with a meniscal gap.

5:52

That reminds me of a funny story that I remember that we've

5:56

Trained a lot of terrific, uh, bone radiologists at UCSD,

6:01

and they've gone out in the communities

6:03

and they do a lot of mr.

6:05

And a number of years ago, uh, one

6:07

of my ex fellows called me

6:09

and said, you know, I really appreciate your training.

6:12

They always start with that.

6:13

They, I really appreciate your training.

6:15

We're really successful here.

6:16

We're doing a lot of knee, uh, mr uh, examinations,

6:21

and I'm curious that if you had to shorten it

6:24

to one sequence, what sequence would you use?

6:29

And I said, well, I I don't wanna really shorten it

6:31

to one sequence, but if I had to choose,

6:34

it would be the coronal fluid sensitive,

6:36

often fat suppressed image.

6:38

'cause on such an image as shown here,

6:41

you can see menisci bone, uh, bruises, uh, fractures.

6:46

You can see some of the ligaments.

6:48

So I said, well, that would be my favorite, uh, image.

6:50

And he said, well, wait, you don't understand.

6:52

I'm really, really busy.

6:55

And if I wanna, in fact, shorten it to one image

7:00

I have, that's why I said I, I can't recommend that.

7:02

But if I had to shortened the MR examination of the knee

7:07

to one image, it would be a coronal image, fat,

7:12

fluid, sensitive through the posterior aspect

7:16

of the meniscus, particularly the medial meniscus.

7:19

And in fact, I'll go further.

7:21

This is the most important single one half image

7:25

of a knee MR examination.

7:27

All right, that you're seeing that over here.

7:30

That is critical. 'cause a lot happens here.

7:35

Radial tears, root ligament problems.

7:37

So you always wanna study.

7:39

Take an extra few seconds to look at this particular area.

7:43

Posterior horn of the medial meniscus.

Report

Faculty

Donald Resnick, MD

Professor Emeritus, Department of Radiology

University of California, San Diego

Mini N. Pathria, MD, FRCP(C)

Division Chief, Musculoskeletal Imaging

University of California San Diego

Eric Y. Chang, MD

Adjunct Professor, Radiology

University of California, San Diego

Brady K. Huang, MD

Clinical Professor of Radiology

UC San Diego Medical Center

Tags

Musculoskeletal (MSK)

MRI

Knee