Upcoming Events
Log In
Pricing
Free Trial

Meniscal Failure Types

HIDE
PrevNext

0:01

As that as background.

0:02

Let's go now to our basic types of meniscal failure.

0:06

We're gonna start with circumferential

0:08

or longitudinal vertical tear.

0:11

Typically what occurs is axial compression placed on the

0:16

superior surface of the meniscus.

0:18

Now what does that do? That produces hoop stress.

0:23

So the initial pattern

0:25

of failure is a microscopic tear,

0:28

and I'm gonna put it in this drawing

0:30

and you'll see why it remains microscopic.

0:33

Here you see it extending

0:35

and it contacts one of those longitudinal

0:38

circumferential collagen bundles,

0:41

which prevents it from extending in this

0:43

particular direction.

0:45

So it takes the path of least resistance

0:48

and that path of least resistance is this vertical

0:53

longitudinal, because it has kind

0:55

of an antral posterior dimension.

0:58

And you see this in the peripheral aspect of the meniscus

1:01

where you have these longitudinal circumferential fibers.

1:06

These types of tears are present often in young people

1:09

following injury.

1:11

And in those involved in a variety of sports,

1:14

a longitudinal vertical tear.

1:17

Now, let's go back to my drawing.

1:19

I kind of like this drawing showing you those red tubes.

1:22

Those are the longitudinal circumferential collagen fibers,

1:26

and I'm throwing in a radial tie fiber.

1:29

And let's go ahead and place in this particular

1:32

transparent meniscus, a longitudinal vertical tear.

1:36

And we're gonna make it a long one.

1:38

So here it comes in yellow.

1:40

The longer this longitudinal vertical tear,

1:44

the more radial tie fibers that are violated.

1:48

And what do the radial tie fibers do?

1:51

They attach the central

1:53

to the peripheral portion of the meniscus.

1:55

So if you have a long longitudinal vertical tear,

2:01

you may get displacement of the inner margin of the meniscus

2:04

with respect to the periphery.

2:06

And what you end up with is a bucket handle tear,

2:10

a displaced longitudinal vertical tear.

2:13

So here's my picture.

2:15

Three dimensional of a longitudinal vertical tear in the

2:18

outer half of the meniscus.

2:20

Here I'm just showing you what it looks like, right?

2:24

You can see where it's located

2:26

between those collagen bundles.

2:28

The lent of this tear relates to its AP

2:31

or circumferential dimension, right?

2:35

We come along and image it in one plane,

2:37

and that's what it looks like.

2:39

And let's stay in the same plane

2:41

and we'll image it again right here.

2:44

And what does it look like? It's boring. It looks the same.

2:48

And by that I mean not only is it vertical,

2:51

but it's the same distance from the margin of the meniscus

2:56

that is characteristic as these tears tend to extend

3:01

between the collagen bundles.

3:03

And if it moves away

3:05

or toward the periphery, it's vertical obl.

3:08

And that, in my view, requires more force.

3:11

So this is the easiest path, the path of least resistance.

3:16

And that is why in fact, this line

3:19

of abnormalities is at the same distance

3:22

to the peripheral margin of the meniscus.

3:25

So here's an example of one first image.

3:28

Second image is boring. Here's another one.

3:31

Alright, here's another one.

3:32

These look pretty much the same on all of the images.

3:38

Now, a longitudinal vertical tear involving the posterior

3:42

horn, okay?

3:44

Of the lateral meniscus where we have a region

3:47

in which the Pope tears tendon extends

3:50

obliquely across the joint.

3:52

That is an area that in many of us has no red zone.

3:56

So that is why in some classification systems,

3:59

this particular type of tear in this location

4:03

gets particular emphasis.

4:07

If we look at a longitudinal vertical tear involving the

4:10

very periphery of the posterior corn of the medial meniscus,

4:16

we are talking about something that has been classified

4:20

as a ramp lesion.

4:22

Now I can tell you, if you read all the articles on ramp

4:26

lesions, you're gonna get a little bit mixed up

4:29

because there isn't in fact definite consistency on

4:33

what a ramp lesion is.

4:35

But let me give you some ideas about it.

4:38

We see it with tears of the anterior cruciate ligament.

4:41

Originally, I learned about it

4:43

as a double vertical peripheral tear involving the posterior

4:47

horn of the medial meniscus with chronic ACL tears.

4:52

Now in fact, that term ramp lesion is applied either

4:55

to chronic or recent pairs

4:58

of the anterior cruciate ligament.

5:00

And whether or not there are double

5:02

or single points of failure,

5:05

and typically that failure is at

5:08

or adjacent to the meniscal capsular junction

5:12

near the posterior horn of the medial meniscus.

5:16

There are certain characteristic findings, two

5:19

of which have been emphasized in the literature.

5:21

I'm showing you examples of what they look like.

5:24

Irregularity of the posterior margin of the posterior horn

5:28

of the medial meniscus.

5:30

And number two, fluid filling the region

5:34

between the posterior horn of the medial meniscus

5:37

and the joint capsule.

5:38

So this is what you are looking for.

5:42

Now, there is a third finding that I find very useful,

5:45

and that is marrow edema in the subj tibia.

5:50

Alright, whenever I find this particular finding,

5:54

particularly when dealing with a

5:56

Patient who has an anterior cruciate ligament tear,

6:00

I've learned, you've gotta look right above it.

6:03

You wanna look for meniscal pathology, you wanna look

6:06

for ramp lesions

6:08

because that can tell you, it kind of is a, a flashlight,

6:12

a bulb that kind of tells you there's something right

6:15

above it, and you're gonna be looking for partial

6:18

or complete pairing near or at the Meniscocapsular junction.

6:23

Now, another point about these longitudinal vertical tears,

6:28

excuse me, they're not always strictly vertical.

6:31

They can be vertical OBL as I show you in the diagram.

6:36

And if they are vertical obl, yeah,

6:38

they'll look vertical in the one plane,

6:41

but they can look horizontal in another plane.

6:44

So be aware of that.

6:46

You may in fact misread these as horizontal tears.

Report

Faculty

Donald Resnick, MD

Professor Emeritus, Department of Radiology

University of California, San Diego

Mini N. Pathria, MD, FRCP(C)

Division Chief, Musculoskeletal Imaging

University of California San Diego

Eric Y. Chang, MD

Adjunct Professor, Radiology

University of California, San Diego

Brady K. Huang, MD

Clinical Professor of Radiology

UC San Diego Medical Center

Tags

Musculoskeletal (MSK)

MRI

Knee