Upcoming Events
Log In
Pricing
Free Trial

MSK Plain Film Imaging, Dr. Donna Magid (11-17-26)

HIDE
PrevNext

0:02

Hello, and welcome to Noon Conference hosted by Modality.

0:05

Noon Conference connects the global radiology community through free live

0:09

educational webinars that are accessible for all and is an opportunity to learn

0:13

alongside top radiologists from around the world.

0:16

Today, we're honored to welcome Dr.

0:18

Donna Magid for a lecture entitled "Read My Hips: Basics of Pelvic Radiography."

0:23

Dr. Magid is a passionate educator and mentor, having run the Johns Hopkins

0:26

radiology medical student elective for over 22 years and overseeing the MSK

0:31

radiography education of the first-year radiology residents for almost as long.

0:35

Her educational website, teamrads.com, provides introductory educational materials

0:40

for medical students and residents, and the Apps of Steel has been a Rad-Match

0:44

guidebook for over 25 years. At the end of the lecture, please join her in a Q&A

0:48

session where she will address questions you may have on today's topic.

0:52

Please remember to use that Q&A feature to submit your questions so we can get to

0:55

as many as we can before our time is up.

0:58

With that, we're ready to begin today's lecture. Dr.

1:01

Magid, please take it from here.

1:03

Okay. So I'm going to discuss pelvic radiography today, so-called X-rays,

1:09

although that's not really the accurate term because most of us, if you're already

1:14

working and not a resident, you're going to find that your lists are longer and

1:17

longer every day with radiographs or plain films stacking up much faster than they

1:23

used to. And the objectives today is to acknowledge that

1:28

radiography has roared back. There was a decade or two where it seemed like it was

1:33

fading. It's back, and it's really back with increased force.

1:38

And I want to revisit some of the essential basics and pitfalls of recording the

1:43

pelvic radiograph, interpreting it, and then just briefly touching on some of the

1:48

hoops we have to jump through these days in order to get billing and for

1:52

medical-legal protection. I have no financial disclosures.

1:56

I read 39,000 radiographs a year, so I do have to disclose I have very strong

2:01

feelings about pelvic radiography.

2:06

Our environment is changing. If you've been in the business for more than 5 or 10

2:11

years, you can already see the change.

2:13

If you've been in longer, as I have, there's been basic changes, not just from

2:19

analog to digital, but massive changes in the patient's access to the records,

2:24

massive changes in the sorts of imaging we have available to us, and unfortunately,

2:28

massive growth in medical litigation.

2:31

We also have an older population now, which means more problems along every sort of

2:37

organ system, and that population tends to insist on being more active

2:43

than we grew up thinking a 75, an 85, a 95-year-old person could be.

2:49

We have people in orthopedic clinic in their 90s complaining that they've had to

2:53

switch from singles to doubles tennis because they can't get around the court fast

2:57

enough. That's actually fantastic, but it also means we're seeing a whole new crop

3:03

of orthopedic and joint problems.

3:05

We also have a surge of non-MDs who are seeing patients, and

3:12

it's been documented, they tend to request more imaging than

3:18

the physicians do. Insurance and approval for other studies like MR often

3:24

rests now on getting the radiographs first.

3:27

So that's something we need to do, whether or not the clinician thought that was

3:31

the next best thing to do. But basically, if you look at the American College of

3:36

Radiology appropriateness criteria, which I think is a much better guideline to

3:40

what sort of imaging we should be getting, as opposed to the insurance companies,

3:45

the entrance way to everything in MSK is through a radiograph.

3:50

The bottom line is no matter what your subspecialty within radiology, likely you're

3:55

going to take call or have to cover some radiography.

3:58

And if you mess up the plain films, no one's going to trust you, no matter how good

4:02

you are at other things.

4:05

When I'm starting out with my med students or junior residents, I tell them

4:08

radiology is the sun. We're now the center of the medical universe.

4:13

Almost all diagnostics, a lot of therapeutics, a lot of prognosis

4:19

rests on our input, and the menu of available imaging has gotten so

4:25

diverse and so complicated that even radiologists aren't sure sometimes

4:29

what study to request next.

4:34

So if you look at the ACR, AC, every musculoskeletal diagnostic

4:40

problem presented in the appropriateness criteria starts with a radiograph.

4:46

It's the best practice. It's what we now call high-value care.

4:50

It's the standard of care, which hopefully you won't have to encounter in a

4:54

courtroom. And again, it's insurance approval and billing, since none of us really

4:59

want to work for free. Radiography remains relatively low dose, it's rapid, and

5:05

it's far more accessible to your average patient than getting a CT or MR, which may

5:10

be weeks or even months away, depending on circumstances.

5:14

And it certainly remains one of the most reasonably priced ways to get into the

5:18

imaging system.

5:22

Now, I spent about 10 years researching and writing about the pelvis and the

5:27

acetabulum and the hip, and I could really understand why a lot of orthopedists

5:32

used to say, "If you understand the hip, you understand orthopedic anatomy." I

5:37

think that's true for the imaging also.

5:39

If you understand some of the basic principles of imaging the pelvis and hips and

5:43

assessing the radiographs before you read them, you really are going to understand

5:47

more about everything you do.

5:50

Even when it's normal, the pelvis is really too complex to just eyeball or gestalt,

5:56

and as it gets increasingly abnormal, it's becoming impossible to actually do

6:02

anything unless you have a very systematic checklist and approach.

6:08

I have 10 commandments online, and the first one, and it really could almost be the

6:12

only one, is trust no one, believe no one, the saboteurs are everywhere.

6:17

That also translates to trust but verify.

6:20

The patients give us information which may or may not be wildly inaccurate, whether

6:25

it's the time frame, the circumstances, whether it's their own personal

6:29

comorbidities. Patients don't always intend to mislead us, but most of them are

6:35

not medically knowledgeable and may give misleading descriptions or may have

6:40

already formed strong opinions from researching it on Google before they spoke to

6:44

you. The clinicians who give us the request tend to be really scanty on

6:50

information. Most of the day in orthopedics, I'm lucky if I get pain or rule out

6:56

fracture. I'd really like to know with one finger where it hurts.

7:01

And then even worse, a lot of people are requesting radiographs after only a

7:05

televisit with a patient or with orthopedic matters or joint matters they don't

7:10

usually deal with, and they might be requesting wildly inappropriate studies.

7:17

I have people who say ankle pain, and then they request a foot, and I need to

7:21

explain that the foot is a limited exam of the ankle.

7:25

Plus, they come in having been seen at other facilities but not having those images

7:30

with them. I've learned if someone went to a walk-in, like strip mall

7:37

clinic, emergency clinic, that the odds are about 50/50 that the

7:43

radiographic reading reported to me by the patient's going to be accurate.

7:47

So if they say, "Patient first told me I had a fracture," or, "Patient first told

7:51

me I don't have a fracture," I have experienced that when I finally see those

7:55

radiographs, I could flip a coin and be just about as accurate.

8:02

Now, the initial thing you have to do on any radiograph you read is you have to

8:06

decide, number one, did they get the right study, and did you get the right

8:12

exam? In our emergency department, where you can have the proverbial 10 to 14-hour

8:18

wait if you don't have a life-threatening illness, this very nice lady walked in

8:22

with her hand over her left lower quadrant, says, "I'm in pain." And when we get

8:27

really backed up, a triage nurse walks around the department, says, "Why are you

8:30

here? Why are you here? Why are you here?" And then requests a radiograph trying to

8:34

keep things moving. So she requested an abdominal radiograph for the lady with left

8:39

lower quadrant pain, and the abdominal pelvic part of it was pretty

8:45

unremarkable, except for fortunately, we have a habit of looking carefully in the

8:50

corners.

8:52

So at the very edge of this image, I caught the tiny cortical discrepancy of a

8:58

subtrochanteric fracture

9:01

Here.

9:03

And the story actually was that she didn't have enough time to tell the triage

9:07

nurse was, "I fell on my left side yesterday, and now it hurts." So she had a

9:12

subtrochanteric fracture, not left lower quadrant pain, and it'd be important to

9:18

recognize that if you don't have the initial accurate history and accurate study,

9:24

you're going to be nowhere with nothing.

9:28

Every report we write has four audiences, which makes it very confusing to reach

9:34

all four audiences because the Venn diagrams of their vocabularies and medical

9:39

experiences barely overlap. The clinician, I consider the main audience.

9:45

They are trying to care for the patient, and I need to communicate very precisely

9:51

with them whether I'm worried or not worried, what I think something is.

9:55

Patients can now read their charts, which is perfectly appropriate, but even a

10:00

highly educated patient may not be medically highly educated, and we've learned

10:05

there are certain words, even with a wonderful, precise medical definition, such as

10:10

obesity, we simply cannot use in the chart because it upsets the patient.

10:16

So we refer to everything as body mass index or habitus, and for some reason, that

10:20

doesn't bother the patients. Then billing and insurance are looking for certain

10:25

formats, right down to the punctuation.

10:28

If you want to get paid for your work, you have to pay attention to that, and it's

10:32

extremely annoying and contributes absolutely nothing to our medical education.

10:37

And then, unfortunately, it's always wise to think about the possibility that a

10:42

lawyer is going to be reading that report.

10:44

I think of it as fastening your seatbelt.

10:46

You fasten your seatbelt every single time you get in your car, and hopefully, you

10:52

never have to test it or use it. So hopefully, you won't get sued, but you always

10:57

phrase everything as if someone might be looking at it with that in mind.

11:02

You'll never find me saying "normal." You'll never find me saying, "No evidence of

11:08

fracture." There's always a little bit of a nice leafy green hedge.

11:12

Our national shrub is radiologist.

11:14

So I'll say, "No definite abnormality." I'll say, "It's unremarkable." I'll say,

11:19

"Follow-up if clinically indicated." And then I'll certainly quantify in every exam

11:25

what I didn't adequately say. I'll start with limited exam of C7 and T1,

11:31

no odontoid view, limited exam of the proximal femur, because again, one

11:37

of my Ten Commandments is lend a foothold to lawyers.

11:43

So my reports should educate the clinician a little bit, and it should certainly

11:48

protect us. So in the pelvis, it's almost always appropriate to start with bowel

11:54

contents and habitus limit detail.

11:57

Some of my patients have a BMI of 80 or 90, and it's hard to see things.

12:03

Then rotation of the pelvis or the proximal femur is also going to affect your

12:08

ability to make an accurate interpretation of that study.

12:12

If I see a sacrum and coccyx study, if I see an SI joint study, the very first

12:18

sentence of the report is, "Radiography provides a limited assessment of these

12:23

areas," because some people won't understand that if I say there's no definite

12:27

abnormality, that there still could be something hiding in these vastly poorly seen

12:33

areas on a radiograph. And then one thing that always makes me a little bit crazy

12:38

is if you ask your grandmother what she's afraid of as she grows older, she says,

12:44

"I'm afraid I'm going to fall and break my hip." What she actually means is she's

12:48

afraid she's going to fracture her proximal femur, although, of course, she's not

12:52

going to say it that way. But medical people should distinguish between the

12:56

proximal femur, the acetabulum, and the hip.

13:01

We shouldn't say things like shoulder dislocation because it's either the

13:05

glenohumeral joint or it's your acromioclavicular joint.

13:08

And again, when you're talking about the pelvis and the hip, you need to be a

13:12

little more precise than the general public.

13:19

So the starting point is position and exposure.

13:23

I have a lot of handouts for reading radiography of the different joints and areas

13:27

on Team Rads, and they all start with assessing the positioning and adequacy of the

13:33

exposure. So in the pelvis, I want to look for the pedicles of the distal lumbar

13:39

spine, the spinous processes, and they should form a nice straight line right

13:43

through the symphysis. This is the most posterior part of the pelvis.

13:48

This is the most anterior part of the pelvis.

13:50

So even a little bit of a step-off between those two areas is going to imply a

13:55

great deal of rotation, which throws off all of your landmarks and all of the

13:59

things you think you're visualizing.

14:01

Then I'm looking for trabeculae all over, and I think of it as hand-drawn graph

14:07

paper that you want to see because Wolf's law says that bones form

14:14

trabeculae according to the forces on them, and the pelvis really talks to me.

14:20

So I'm going to start looking, again, for the pedicles, spinous process, that

14:25

straight line. I want to see at least two, maybe three pairs of neural foramina

14:30

roofs in the sacrum, and I want to make sure I can see things posteriorly.

14:36

If I can't, I'm going to say exposure factors or habitus and/or bowel contents

14:42

limit detail. I've already established whether or not it's rotated, and

14:48

the other thing I'm going to look at for the pelvic ring, the obturator foramen

14:52

should be perfectly symmetric. If they're at all asymmetric, there's rotation, and

14:57

in something this bulky, all your other observations will be off.

15:02

Then the medial wall, I'm going to show you in a couple of slides, there's some

15:05

very subtle soft tissue here, and when I can see the fascial planes there, I know

15:10

there's no inflammation, no major trauma, no infection, no bleeding, no ascites.

15:17

So that line can be very important to me, even though it's an area often poorly

15:20

visualized because of all the superimposed soft tissue.

15:24

Then there are lines I follow starting up at the sacrum, iliopubic, and then they

15:30

start in the same place, and it becomes ilioischial.

15:33

This is actually the anterior and posterior columns of the anterior rings are very

15:39

important for weight-bearing. I'm going to look at the teardrop, which we'll look

15:43

at more in just a minute. The acetabular roof just runs from about 10 o'clock to 2

15:49

o'clock because of this cotyloid fossa, and then there should be crisscrossing

15:53

trabeculae in the dome where the weight-bearing forces are all coming together to

15:57

hit this one little surface of the acetabular roof. Then we have to look hard.

16:02

In most patients, you can find the anterior and posterior rims of the

16:07

acetabulum. You can't always, but if you have to look for it or you're going to

16:12

miss very subtle fractures. And then, of course, like the lady with the "left lower

16:16

quadrant pain," then I look around the corners and all the different things that

16:20

aren't at all related to the pelvis and hip, just to see if anything strange is

16:24

going on.

16:26

But here's that pelvic side wall. So we've got some soft tissue here and some

16:31

bladder, but you've got this very fine line of muscle and a little bit of fat and

16:35

fascia, and again, that is actually lying against a very large surface area of the

16:41

quadrilateral plate surface, which I'll be showing you in a few slides.

16:45

And the fact that it's normal and symmetric with the other side is very reassuring

16:50

to me.

16:53

Again, Wolf's law. Wolf actually developed this theory before there was

16:58

radiography, which I find really impressive.

17:01

And I always tell the residents and students that bones talk to me, and what I mean

17:05

is that the trabeculae speak in that the way they look tells me their

17:11

history of weight-bearing and of stresses.

17:14

So all the weight of the body comes down through the acetabular dome with its

17:18

crisscrossed hand-drawn trabeculae.

17:21

It forms the very condensed acetabular roof from about 10 o'clock to 2 o'clock, and

17:26

then the weight-bearing forces continue down into the femurs.

17:30

It's a fairly straight shot of compression down to the medial cortex, but since we

17:35

have femoral necks, we need these bending or tensile trabeculae that carry the

17:41

forces out and eventually become the lateral cortex.

17:44

There's a little traffic island in the middle, Ward's triangle, a relatively

17:48

loosened area. The femoral neck is filled with red marrow, and it can be prone to

17:53

infection or to neoplasm. But in most patients, this triangle is absolutely,

17:59

completely normal and has to be recognized

18:05

So again, weight-bearing forces come down,

18:10

and they go into direct compression medial, and then the lateral cortex.

18:15

And these two cortices are the strongest cortices in the body, except for maybe the

18:20

iliac crest, and they reflect the very focal concentration of weight-bearing

18:25

forces.

18:28

And one thing I should mention, I'm sure when you were little, you all jumped on

18:31

your parents' scales to see how much you could make yourself weigh.

18:35

And when all these weight-bearing forces come through here, they get magnified by 8

18:40

to 12 pounds. So if your upper body weighs 100 pounds, we're talking about

18:46

1,200 pounds of force through these trabeculae, which is why trying to see every

18:50

single trabecula is going to be so important.

18:55

When I look at the pelvis, I start at the sacrum because it's the easiest to miss.

19:00

It's a big, bulky bone. It's tilted back at about 45 degrees.

19:05

It's got a lot of air and feces and habitus over it, and it's overall pretty easy

19:11

to not understand how little of it you're seeing.

19:15

So I'm going to look for those neural foramina roofs, at least two pairs, hopefully

19:19

three pairs. I'm going to look for the pedicles and the straight line lining it up.

19:24

We're never going to see the whole SI joint.

19:27

It undulates not just cephalocaudal but medially lateral.

19:31

It's actually a very broad surface area.

19:34

So again, I'm never going to claim I saw the whole thing, but I'll say the

19:37

visualized portions are unremarkable or symmetric or whatever I think they are.

19:46

And again, when you start at the sacrum and go through here, look at the obturator

19:50

foramina. Now, the problem is that the sacrum also has these

19:56

pseudoarthroses, which are remarkably common.

20:00

And when I'm checking my residents or my MSK fellows, they miss two or three of

20:06

these a day every day. They just don't notice them because it's so easy to ignore

20:12

the sacrum. The pseudoarthrosis or the transitional anatomy per se isn't

20:18

the major cause of back pain, but back pain is usually a conglomerate of multiple

20:23

causes. And if you don't recognize and diagnose this cause of it, it might get left

20:28

out of the fusion. And I've seen surgery that only stopped at L5 instead of

20:34

continuing through the transitional anatomy, and then two years later had to be

20:38

extended.

20:41

So again, these pseudoarthrosis transitional anatomy, if you always start at the

20:46

sacrum, you'll tend not to miss them.

20:52

And again, we miss, or my residents almost miss about two a day.

21:01

You have pedicles,

21:03

spinous processes coming down in a straight line.

21:08

Neural foramina roofs,

21:11

whatever you can see of the SI joints, looking for transitional anatomy.

21:17

Now, the SI joint is not completely a joint.

21:21

The real synovial joint is down here, the distal third.

21:24

The rest of this is bound by the strongest ligaments in the body.

21:30

The implication being if you see following trauma, widening or asymmetry

21:36

anywhere along the SI joint, that implies massive trauma because to rip those

21:41

ligaments apart and widen the SI joint takes really significant force, not just

21:48

a fall from stance.

21:50

And if the clinician feels pelvic instability on exam, then even if the radiograph

21:56

is massively limited, they should get a CT to check it out.

22:02

Here is sacrum with neural foramina roofs.

22:06

I see this roof, and I totally don't see that.

22:09

This could be bowel gas,

22:12

but you should be a little bit suspicious.

22:14

In actuality, it's a lytic lesion that big, and if the patient had a little

22:20

more air and feces in their colon, it wouldn't have been noticed at all.

22:25

So it's sort of a trust no one, believe no one.

22:27

I'm always sure there's something lurking in the sacrum that wants me to miss it.

22:35

Then here again, slightly limited exposure, nice obturator foramina,

22:41

and the femoral necks are not quite completely seen.

22:45

I need to see biconcavity here, which means the patients have to turn their toes

22:50

inward, and a patient in pain wants to

22:54

evert their feet. So minimally limited exam of the proximal femurs, and then

22:59

exposure factors limit visualization of the posterior pelvis.

23:02

Now here I've got one or two neural foramina roofs. They look like eyebrows.

23:07

I have one here that's a little bit dysmorphic compared to that one, which is just

23:12

completely convex. And then this one's a little bit blurred.

23:16

So actually, this loss of detail in the sacrum here

23:21

is a markedly large lytic lesion going into the neural foramina, going right up to

23:27

the margins of the SI joints. And unfortunately, all you're going to get

23:34

is this little bit of change in the neural foramina roofs.

23:39

But if you're paying attention and you start with the sacrum, you may pick that up.

23:43

Again, if your patient weighs 400 pounds and is massively constipated, you're going

23:49

to miss it. But then again, if you've learned not to say normal with no evidence

23:53

of, but visualized portions without definite abnormality, but limited exam of the

23:59

posterior pelvis, you're going to be more accurate.

24:06

So again, it's why I'm so careful to phrase things.

24:10

I also know I just haven't seen anything.

24:12

This is a really large structure, and I know I can't see the whole thing on

24:18

radiograph no matter how many views I get.

24:20

So I always know that I can only comment on the pieces that I saw.

24:29

Now, this patient fell at home and is complaining of pain, no localizing

24:34

information. And if you start with the positioning, fairly symmetric obturator

24:39

foramina, fairly symmetric vertical line through the midline.

24:45

And if you follow your iliopubic lines,

24:51

this one gets a little bit fuzzy. And then if you're looking for your trabecula,

24:55

things get a little bit patchy here.

24:58

So in actuality, although we're looking for trauma from the history, what she has

25:03

is a pathologic fracture through her first presentation of myeloma.

25:08

So falling probably helped increase her odds of surviving this diagnosis.

25:15

But again, these findings aren't going to jump out at you on a very busy, complex

25:19

film. You're going to have to follow these guidelines and look for bilateral

25:23

symmetry.

25:28

Why is pelvic trauma so devastating? This is a hemipelvis.

25:33

We're standing in the patient's bladder. Here's the symphysis.

25:37

Here's the bisected sacrum, so this is anterior, posterior.

25:42

And here's this whole medial wall of the pelvis, the quadrilateral plate surface.

25:49

It's a little bit bigger than the side of your hands, than the palm of your hands.

25:53

And closely applied to it are all of the nerves, arteries, and veins,

25:59

plus a lot of the genitourinary system.

26:02

And anything violent enough to disrupt this is going to wreak

26:08

havoc on all of these vessels, nerves, and genitourinary structures.

26:15

So pelvic ring fractures pretty much fall into two categories.

26:19

So half of them are the elderly. And fortunately, since those people are more

26:25

fragile, they usually fell from stance, they fell from ground level,

26:31

and 95% of them, even with fractures, are less catastrophic.

26:36

Now, of course, that's changing. Our 80 and 90-year-olds want to ride bicycles and

26:41

hike up mountains, and some of them are coming in with higher velocity injuries

26:45

now. It tends to be traditionally younger people who come in with

26:52

the more morbidity, mortality initial injuries from very

26:57

high forces, motor vehicle collisions, pedestrian struck or bicyclist struck, fall

27:03

from heights, rock climbing. Of course, the pedestrian struck and the cyclist

27:07

struck includes all age groups at this point, especially since COVID, when everyone

27:11

started going outside and walking all the time.

27:15

That those fractures with the higher forces, much more bleeding, much more damage

27:20

to all the organ systems. There can be a very high initial mortality from the

27:25

hemorrhagic shock, and then there's a very great chance of long-term morbidity

27:31

to all the different organ systems involved.

27:34

Plus the fact that your initial mobility and overall well-being is going to be

27:40

compromised by the prolonged recovery period.

27:43

And then young females may have additional problems with reproduction from all the

27:49

fibrosis, scar tissue, and damage.

27:56

So there are standard views that are very easy to get.

28:00

The AP view is the one most of us see, and again, assess the obturator foramen,

28:07

the midline here. Make sure that your

28:11

toes have been turned in so that you get that biconcavity of the femoral necks,

28:16

since the femoral neck is of great interest.

28:21

And then the good thing is there are other views we can get of the pelvis without

28:27

moving a potentially fractured or fragile patient, because most

28:33

joints we say one view is no view, and you need at least two or three views at 90

28:37

degrees to each other to really say you've seen it.

28:40

You don't want to roll a patient with possible pelvic fractures on their sides for

28:45

the obliques. So you can take the tube and roll it

28:51

up towards the patient's head and shoot down into the pelvis for an inlet view that

28:56

elongates things, lets you see a little bit more of the SI joint and sacrum, shows

29:00

you a slightly different view of your pelvic sidewalls, and then you can roll the

29:04

tube to the patient's feet and get an outlet view, which again gives you a really

29:10

nice view of the SI joints and sacrum, stretches out the anterior rings and gives

29:15

you three views, not quite at 90 degrees to each other, but better than no

29:21

view at 90 degrees to each other. The other good thing about these views is that

29:26

you can reproduce them easily in clinic at follow-up, even if the patient has

29:31

limited mobility and is still recovering from the fracture.

29:35

So we tend to not get the Jude obliques in patients with injuries or potential

29:41

injuries or recovering from injuries.

29:46

The other misperception is that if you get a frontal and lateral of the hip, quote

29:51

unquote, "You've gotten two views at 90 degrees." I have gotten two views at 90

29:56

degrees of my proximal femur, and that's very nice, especially since the femoral

30:01

neck is of incredible interest in pelvic trauma.

30:05

But if you look carefully at the acetabulum, the cotyloid fossa, the ischium,

30:11

this is absolutely the same view. This is like getting internal, external views of

30:16

the proximal humerus. The humerus is perfectly capable of rotating at least 90

30:22

degrees, but you're getting similar views of the rest of the bony shoulder or the

30:27

rest of the bony pelvis and hip when you get those two views.

30:35

Then, of course, there's going to be patients who roll into the trauma center, and

30:38

this is what you get next. You obviously cannot give a very detailed read.

30:43

You're going to start out with the limitations.

30:46

But remember that the only thing we all have to get right, every single case, every

30:52

day, the only thing you absolutely have to get right is worry, don't worry.

30:59

Everything else is details. If you get that part wrong, nothing matters, whatever

31:03

else you say. It's not normal or abnormal because many of our patients are

31:09

not normal, haven't been normal for a long time, and will never be normal again.

31:13

So it's worry, don't worry that you have to keep in mind.

31:18

And since we see some rather unusual patients in our practice, it's a tertiary

31:22

referral practice, I just always have to keep remembering, worry, don't worry,

31:27

because some of the cases are very abnormal.

31:33

And then actually, you know on that previous patient, you know the patient's going

31:38

to get a CT. You know the patient has multiple catastrophic injuries.

31:43

You can see some of them radiographically already.

31:46

But actually, the ones that are more worrisome in the day-to-day practice are the

31:50

patients that seem to be maybe okay or had trauma a couple of days ago, so it

31:55

couldn't be that serious. And there are times that patients are either amazingly

32:00

stoic or determined or really need to get to work or are

32:06

afraid of doctors or of institutions that might want to see their papers.

32:12

And they may also have the opportunity to self-medicate, so people don't always

32:16

come in right away with trauma. So again, you take someone like this, it's a little

32:22

rotated. My obturator foramen are not symmetric, but it's not too rotated.

32:28

We have nice biconcavity, figure of eight for these femoral necks.

32:32

But if I start following my lines, there's a small step off here that

32:38

isn't on that side. So that would be very worrisome, and this is someone who took a

32:44

fall a day or two ago and fell off of a horse onto a log,

32:50

didn't think it was too bad, but actually has

32:54

a medial pelvic wall fracture. And I can see a little bit of that fascia for the

33:00

medial pelvic wall. I don't see other things. It was a young person.

33:04

Their vital signs were stable. They brought themselves in.

33:09

They did get inlet, outlet views of this person, and

33:15

I wouldn't have thought the patient needed a CT, but we're always going to do more

33:20

CT than we think because we've all had such unpleasant surprises.

33:23

People are litigious, people are bad historians, and you just don't know people

33:28

have comorbidities. So in this case, the CT only added better visualization of that

33:34

medial wall edema, and this is at normal medial wall soft tissue.

33:39

And this is two sides of a coin. We overutilize CT.

33:44

There's a lot of cost involved. There's a lot of dose involved.

33:47

But we also have patients with a lot of uncertainty who are going to have weird

33:51

things we didn't expect. We have patients with lawyers.

33:55

We have patients who aren't good historians or aren't giving you the whole story

33:59

for one reason or another. So I know we overuse CT, but particularly depending

34:05

on the nature of your clinical circumstances, I don't think it's avoidable.

34:09

And we have to remember that radiologists and clinicians have to be the ones to set

34:14

the parameters for who gets a CT or who insurance approves for CT, as opposed

34:20

to the non-medical people who run insurance companies.

34:29

So there's clinical pressure to try and decrease CT because of cost and dose.

34:34

Then in some places, there's a very long wait for a CT scan, which is not really

34:39

acceptable. And the fact that there will continue to be

34:44

economic and institutional and insurance company pressure to

34:50

decrease utilization is only going to bring you back to the more radiographs and to

34:55

the importance of getting everything right on the radiograph.

34:59

There's an incredible amount of information to be mined off of radiographs, which

35:03

we somewhat forgot to do over the last 10 or 15 years when we thought radiography

35:08

might disappear. So here's somebody with fractures, vertical

35:13

fractures through the medial wall and the ischium, fracture of the synthesis,

35:19

pelvic sidewall here, a little bit of edema.

35:22

But this was a young person, very low velocity trauma, vital signs, everything

35:27

else, totally unremarkable. Then what's most important are the things you can't see

35:31

on the radiograph. Is this a reliable patient?

35:36

Do they have a stable living situation?

35:39

They can't live somewhere where they have to walk up five floors to get home.

35:42

They can't be living on the street or in the back of their car.

35:46

And if they have upper body injuries of any sort, they're not going to be able to

35:51

protect this fracture if we treat it conservatively.

35:55

So there are things that the radiologist doesn't know.

35:58

We can just describe what we see, and then all of these non-medical factors also

36:04

come into play. In this case, everything was working in this patient's favor,

36:08

including the social circumstances, the living circumstances, the upper body

36:12

strength. And she didn't get a CT. She did absolutely great, and by two months, she

36:17

was feeling normal and carefully resuming her activities

36:26

So again, radiology quality and assessment.

36:28

Here's the way those force lines flow through from the acetabulum

36:34

and down through the neck and those artick or tensile trabecula.

36:38

It's easiest to see in a slightly osteopenic patient, and I really try to see

36:44

every trabecula. It's not really possible, but I try, because you might only get

36:49

one or two crumpled trabecula for a femoral neck fracture.

36:53

And especially when they're a little bit demineralized, this Ward triangle in the

36:57

middle is totally normal, and it should look like the other side. It's easier.

37:03

Now, here's the more conventional trabecula in a younger person with less bone

37:07

loss. And again, I'm looking for just one or two crumpled trabecula in this raft

37:13

paper here, and I've picked up little tiny fractures that way.

37:17

They're not all going to look like someone turned the bone into corn flakes and

37:21

dropped it back in. Those fractures, they don't really need a radiologist for the

37:26

really big fractures. They need a radiologist for the really subtle ones that you

37:30

might say, "Oh, I don't think anything's wrong." And then 10 or 14 days later, the

37:36

osteoclasts are resorbing the subtle fracture, and the hip gives way, and they fall

37:40

down a flight of steps, or they get in a car accident, or they hit a child because

37:44

they can't brake fast enough in a truck.

37:47

So again, you've got to assess the image quality and then look for the trabecula in

37:52

a properly positioned biconcave proximal femoral neck.

37:59

So here we are back to that hemipelvis.

38:02

This time, the synthesis is to your right, so the patient's looking this way.

38:06

They're sitting on their ischial tuberosity, as probably most of us are right now.

38:11

Acetabulum. And there's a series of arches here, the major one coming down

38:17

through the iliac crests and forming the acetabulum, then continuing.

38:21

The arch is the structurally strongest design in architecture,

38:27

and there are ancient arches held together just by the interlock of stone that are

38:31

5,000 years old and still standing.

38:34

Our bones form multiple arches over inherently vulnerable

38:40

parts of our body, like the brain, the thorax, the pelvis.

38:43

It protects, it can transfer more weight, it can take more trauma.

38:48

So you're going to see arcs and curves and arches everywhere.

38:55

And people always say, "Well, rings fracture in two places." That's

39:01

good to remember, but it's not completely gospel.

39:05

I always think of the pelvis as being closer to a stale bagel than a very crisp

39:10

pretzel ring. It can, with enough force, rupture in two places.

39:15

It doesn't have to, especially the anterior ring.

39:19

It takes much less force to disrupt the anterior ring.

39:22

You can have relatively minor fractures to the anterior ring that leave the

39:26

posterior ring intact. But if you start out being suspicious and going, "I'm going

39:31

to look for the second or third fracture," you're going to do better overall.

39:36

And pelvic fractures are a very small percentage of the fractures seen in the

39:41

United States every year, but they end up being related to the third cause of death

39:47

for multiple trauma, for polytrauma, primarily because of the incredible bleeding

39:52

from all those vessels I showed you against the pelvic sidewall, and partially

39:57

because the enormous force it takes to fracture the pelvis also hits every other

40:02

organ system related to it. Here is that weight-bearing arch of the

40:07

acetabulum. The forces come down from the body, and then they go down the posterior

40:12

column, which is much more robust and takes much more of the weight-bearing.

40:17

The anterior column is relatively thinner, and again, it's a slightly

40:22

lopsided arch, but it's very strong.

40:29

Again, the checklist. You're looking for those six lines.

40:33

You're looking for the neural foramina. You're looking for the iliopubic line.

40:39

You're looking for the ilioischial line, and together they form that upside down Y,

40:44

the slightly lopsided Y of the posterior column and the anterior column.

40:49

You want to look at the acetabular roof, which stops here because of the colloid

40:54

fossa, which is relatively more radiolucent.

40:57

And then the teardrop is this strange line in here.

41:01

It can be more of a true drop. It can be a little bit of a U.

41:05

A lot of people over the years made a lot out of the symmetry or shape of the

41:10

teardrop. It turns out to be primarily dependent on whether or not there's slight

41:16

rotation here, and the shape of the teardrop really doesn't matter.

41:22

So here's those anterior and posterior guidelines.

41:29

So the teardrop was a mystery for a long time.

41:32

Here, for instance, this one's a little bit wider than that one.

41:36

But if you really look carefully, the obturator foramina are not 100% identical and

41:42

symmetric. So for a long time, people go like, "What is this teardrop?" Because if

41:46

you took a cadaver pelvis, you couldn't find anything on it that actually looked

41:51

like that when you took off all the soft tissue.

41:55

So it turns out that the teardrop is this entire quadrilateral plate surface,

42:02

very large area. So it's this whole medial wall of the pelvis and

42:08

acetabulum, and it's seen on our view, it's just a summation

42:14

of the whole thing, so that the teardrop being radiodense

42:20

or radiolucent or lytic, it implies a lesion that can be as big as this

42:27

and only show up on the radiograph as that one little loop medial to the

42:32

acetabulum. So the teardrop's a very important checkpoint.

42:38

So here's one teardrop. Here's a wider teardrop, but again, the obturator foramina

42:44

are not symmetric. So again, the old literature that talked about open, closed,

42:49

cross, J-shaped teardrops, that doesn't matter.

42:52

Those are all pretty much indications of, in most cases, subtle rotation of the

42:57

pelvis until you get to the extremes with extreme acetabular protrusio, but there's

43:02

better landmarks for that.

43:09

So here's a patient where, again, it's difficult to see things.

43:12

There's been surgery, there's air and feces in the bowel.

43:16

Obturator foramina are not quite symmetric, but when I look at the teardrops here,

43:21

this one's filled in, and this is actually blastic prostate

43:27

disease occupying most of the medial wall of the acetabulum, which hadn't been

43:33

diagnosed before.

43:36

So again, the teardrop is filled in.

43:40

Even these few millimeters of density, they imply a huge area of bony involvement.

43:48

Then another thing that's hard to see, but you have to make yourself look for it on

43:51

every image, you have to try and find the anterior and the posterior rim of the

43:57

acetabulum, because if you look at a patient on CT, this is the right hip,

44:01

patient's on their back. Here's the abdomen and pelvis.

44:05

The anterior rim of the acetabulum is ever so slightly medial to the

44:10

posterior. So when you take a straight AP view in a 12 positions, you're going to

44:16

see these anterior margins, posterior margins.

44:21

And occasionally you can't see it just because there's so much stuff superimposed

44:26

or the exposure factor or the rotation is off.

44:28

But when you do see it, it's very helpful because with pelvic trauma, if the line

44:33

of the fracture only comes to there, it's the relatively more gracile

44:39

anterior column. If the line keeps going to there, it's a posterior column

44:44

fracture, which implies a lot more trauma and a lot more possible

44:49

morbidities. Here's that skeletal hemipelvis again, synthesis, acetabulum.

44:55

It takes more force to fracture this part than this part.

44:59

So if you get into the anterior rim, it implies much less force than the posterior.

45:05

Here's on a sagittal image facing to your left, anterior rim of the pelvis,

45:11

posterior rim of the pelvis. And again, you can see it's going to take a lot more

45:15

force, and there's a lot more chance of other collateral damage from this in here.

45:26

So CT is very helpful in pelvic trauma.

45:30

I'm not going to get into it in the confines of this lecture, but you want to know

45:34

if the surfaces, if the fracture involves the acetabular Articular surface.

45:40

Is there continuity of the surface?

45:44

How many times is it disrupted? Is there continuity? Is there congruity?

45:50

Are the pieces displaced? And then for surgical planning, a fracture like this

45:55

where there's relatively minimal comminution, the orthopedic surgeons can measure

46:00

the exact length and number of screws they might need for plate and screw fixation,

46:06

whereas if this looked like cornflakes on the CT and the reconstructions, they'd

46:10

have to rethink their surgical approach.

46:13

It also lets them pick up small intra-articular fragments that you need to fish out

46:17

before you fix the acetabulum, which are much more difficult to see on radiography.

46:26

So again, in terms of those anterior and posterior rims, so in this patient, I see

46:31

a very faint anterior and posterior rim, and on this side there's a fracture

46:36

line. Here's the anterior rim, and this fracture keeps going to the posterior rim.

46:43

So even though it looks relatively non-displaced and on this image may be small,

46:48

you have to assume there was a lot more force involved than if it had only been the

46:52

anterior rim of the acetabulum.

46:56

And again, on CT, that's exactly what you see, is posterior rim, not very

47:01

displaced, not very comminuted, so they can probably treat this conservatively if

47:07

the patient has good upper body strength, if the patient has good living situation

47:11

and some social support. But presumably, if those circumstances are met, this

47:17

patient can be given a try of conservative, whereas if it were a bigger or more

47:21

comminuted fracture, they'd spend more time in the hospital, and they'd debate

47:25

whether or not they should do surgery.

47:30

The acetabular roof, again, just 10 o'clock to 2 o'clock.

47:35

There's this radiolucency here in the fovea that both are very misleading to my

47:40

students and my residents when they're starting out.

47:42

And the acetabular dome has that crisscrossing, hand-drawn graph paper trabecula.

47:48

You've got the roof here. And again, 100% of the body weight transfers to that

47:54

roof and then transfers down the neck, down to the femurs.

47:57

And remember, even in a relatively thin patient, normal habitus, when they're

48:03

running down the steps, that weight can increase to 800 to 1,200 pounds through the

48:08

femoral neck and the intertrochanteric femur.

48:12

So you're doing your 10,000 steps a day and you're running, you're getting a lot of

48:16

wear and tear on your hips and on your proximal femur.

48:24

There's the dome,

48:27

the roof.

48:30

So again, I can't emphasize that too much.

48:33

People don't realize how much weight goes through the femur, and in an older

48:38

patient who might be a little demineralized or someone who's been chronically ill,

48:42

that weight transfer, even if they're not very active, there's still a

48:46

magnification of forces, and I've got to look for one or two crumpled trabecula to

48:51

give me a clue before there's a major catastrophe.

48:57

Again, the trabecula, and they're not always easy to see, but it's got to be one of

49:02

those things you just put on your mental checklist and then look for it every

49:06

single time.

49:08

And when the trabecula, this looks like it could be air and feces, although it's

49:12

a little bit too lateral, when in fact it's myeloma taking out the acetabulum.

49:18

This area has tons and tons of red marrow.

49:21

It's a very popular landing spot for myeloma or for neoplasm, and it's also the

49:27

part of the pelvis we see most poorly because of air and feces.

49:31

So mentally, we get in the habit of ignoring things there, which is very dangerous.

49:38

Now, I mentioned before that hip fractures is really not a term that physicians

49:43

should use or radiologists should use.

49:45

It's proximal femoral fractures, and it is one of our most expensive

49:51

diseases. Numerically, it's only about 14% of all fractures in the United States

49:57

every year, but it adds up to well over 50% of all the fracture costs, no matter

50:03

how you add it up. It adds up to about $10 billion a year of medical expenses, of

50:08

work lost, of gross national product lost.

50:11

It's a very expensive disease, and it's increasing because people are living to an

50:17

older age. They're living with disease instead of dying from disease, and they have

50:23

expectations, in many cases, of staying more active decades longer than your

50:28

grandparents or great-grandparents might have expected.

50:33

So by 80 years old, which used to be really old, a significant number of the

50:38

population has had a fracture, but these days, even 90 years old is not

50:44

extraordinary, and we have a huge number of supercentenarians, thousands and

50:48

thousands of people well over 100.

50:50

So by 90, a third of females and a sixth of males have fractured their proximal

50:55

femur. For many reasons, the immobility, the pulmonary embolus,

51:00

the deconditioning, everything else, the mortality for an older person from a

51:06

femoral neck fracture is enormous.

51:09

Even under ideal circumstances, it's up to 20% the first year, and we have many,

51:15

many very fragile people in these older age groups or in suboptimal living

51:20

situations or with comorbidities that keep them from having an uneventful recovery

51:26

or with nutritional problems that keep them from healing or with dementia that

51:30

keeps them from protecting themselves.

51:32

So this is becoming an increasingly expensive and complicated problem.

51:38

So the bottom line here is we are seeing a ton more radiographs, pelvis and

51:43

otherwise, and we absolutely have to read them really well.

51:48

It doesn't matter how well you can push a catheter or do an ultrasound or read an

51:53

MR or a PET-CT, you're going to have to read radiographs, and your clinicians are

51:58

going to be a little skeptical if you can't read the radiograph.

52:01

They're not sure they're going to be able to trust you.

52:04

Plus, the volume is increasing. We're just going to have to do it.

52:07

It is the entranceway to medical imaging and to medical care.

52:14

Just in case you haven't seen turtle hips before, these are turtle hips.

52:18

I do a lot of work for the Maryland Zoo, and I hope everybody has a happy, healthy

52:22

Thanksgiving if you celebrate. Thank you.

52:27

Thanks so much for that lecture. We're going to open the floor for some questions,

52:33

and we have a few in the Q&A. Let me see if I can sift through these.

52:38

Could you please explain how to make the diagnosis of pincer impingement rapidly?

52:44

A diagnosis of what?

52:46

Pincer impingement.

52:49

Well, on radiographs, you're going to see the superolateral

52:54

acetabulum slightly extended like a big osteophyte, and you may see

53:00

the inferolateral acetabulum also extended.

53:04

So you're extending the arc or the radius of the curve of the acetabulum over the

53:09

head. So pincer impingement implies two crab claws grabbing the head.

53:16

Usually, the head's covered just over 50%, and if you have extensions of the

53:21

acetabulum like that, it's going to be more than 50%.

53:24

And therefore, when you get to the extremes of your range of motion, you're going

53:28

to impinge or hit those bones against the femoral head and neck.

53:36

I always tell my residents, when you have a degenerated hip of some sort,

53:42

I usually say arthritis and/or impingement, or if it looks a little bit more like

53:47

impingement, impingement and/or arthritis.

53:50

Because if it's advanced enough, you can't tell which came first, and if it's very

53:56

early, you're probably going to need more advanced imaging to really

54:01

look for the very subtle details. But in radiography, it would be the superior and

54:06

inferolateral acetabular extensions.

54:11

Thank you. Let me see if I can make sense of this question.

54:14

When a clinician is reporting fracture in pelvic radiography and still recommending

54:19

CT, it's not our job to refuse that. Is that the right practice?

54:25

Well,

54:27

we have to be careful what we suggest.

54:29

My clinicians are happier if I say, "If clinically indicated, CT may provide

54:35

additional information." There are times that I feel very strongly about it, and I

54:40

document, "Discussed with clinician, CT has been requested." But the

54:46

clinicians feel if I mention that it could be obtained, they're obliged to get it

54:50

unless I say "if clinically indicated," and we often discuss it.

54:54

They push for CT sometimes when we feel- It isn't really necessary.

55:00

And then they skip CT sometimes when we think, "Well, I'd really be more

55:04

comfortable. I can't see much on this radiograph.

55:06

He weighs 300 pounds and wasn't prepped for this exam."

55:12

It's a discussion with our clinicians. We're taking care of patients with them.

55:18

I don't like the phrase order an exam.

55:21

It implies that we're a pizza and you can just request what you want from the

55:25

radiologist. We're like any other consult.

55:28

You are requesting a consultation from a physician in a subspecialty.

55:34

And in our institution, we're very lucky our orthopedic surgeons and emergency

55:40

medicine people consider us complete participants in the patient care process and

55:45

decision-making. But you're dealing with some people who just think they can check

55:49

it off on a piece of paper and fax it in, and we're going to do just what they say,

55:52

even if it's totally unwarranted for any reason, clinically or dose-wise or

55:58

cost-wise or evidence-wise.

56:02

Thank you.

56:06

I use the terminology negative pelvis or negative shoulder.

56:09

Is this better than saying normal, or should I drop the negative and just say no

56:13

definitive abnormality?

56:15

I'm much happier with no definite abnormality or visualized portions unremarkable

56:21

because those are bulky structures, and I know I haven't seen every single aspect

56:26

of it. And the last 10 to 15 years, when I get asked to do medical-legal

56:31

consulting, which I pretty much dislike,

56:36

the cases seem more and more to be resting on the phrasing the radiologist used as

56:41

opposed to actual malfeasance. And I've been very upset when I can't

56:47

defend a radiologist because they simply used such rigid language or such

56:53

certainty, or they didn't acknowledge the limits of the study.

56:57

So, I pretty much learned from the cases that I've been asked to look at by

57:02

lawyers. I pretty much learned it's really important to acknowledge the limitations

57:07

and leave yourself a little bit of a back door out.

57:11

Great. Thank you. I think we'll wrap there. Thank you so much for your time, Dr.

57:16

Maggie. This was an amazing presentation, and we really appreciate you being here.

57:20

Thank you. Thank you very much.

57:22

Absolutely. And thank you for everyone else for participating in this noon

57:25

conference. You will get a replay

57:29

link via email later today, and you can access the rest of our noon conferences by

57:34

creating a free account. Be sure to join us next week, Tuesday, November 24th at

57:38

12:00 PM Eastern, where Dr. David Yusim will deliver a lecture entitled Cervical

57:42

Spine Imaging ED Protocols. You can register for that at medallie.com.

57:47

Follow us on social media for updates on future noon conferences.

57:50

Thanks again for learning with us. Have a great day.

Report

Tags

Musculoskeletal (MSK)